Shoes?

Yesterday, I was sitting in my igloo with Tukercheese. We both had the same shoes on. For some reason, when I clicked on Tukercheese, I could click on HIS shoes. When I did so, the shoes appeared to come off Tukercheese on his player card. But that was not true, because when I Xed out of his card and clicked again the shoes were still on. Then I saw the shoes were off ME! I put them back on and freaked.
Today, Penguin86294965 had the same shoes on as ME. The same story, only I didn't flip out.

This is not made up, Max4609 is a witness.